insurance Claim Services
(678 ) 750-3338

If you received a call from this number, it’s in reference to:

First-party appraisal clause

Claim Settlement Services

An appraisal report establishes an opinion of value. But when the insurance company and policyholder still cannot agree on the amount of loss, the claim may move into the policy's appraisal-clause process. That creates additional work beyond preparing the original valuation.

Settlement services are separate from the valuation report and are performed only when additional appraisal-clause work is needed.

Claim Settlement at a Glance
When it beginsAfter the amount of loss remains disputed and appraisal is invoked
APPRAISAL
Settlement rateAdditional appraisal-clause work is billed by time
$300/hr
Normal client capDesigned to keep the cost reasonable relative to the result
25% max
When settlement services occur

A valuation dispute can become a separate appraisal-clause proceeding.

First-party appraisal is generally used when coverage is not the central dispute, but the policyholder and insurance company disagree about the amount of loss. The exact process depends on the policy, but the basic sequence usually looks like this.

1

Carrier values the loss

The insurer makes an offer or establishes its own amount of loss.

2

You dispute the amount

An independent valuation shows that the amount of loss should be different.

3

Appraisal is invoked

The appraisal clause is activated under the applicable policy terms, and each side appoints an appraiser.

4

The appraisers work the dispute

The appraisers exchange support, attempt to agree on the amount of loss and, when necessary, proceed through the umpire process.

Why there is a separate charge

The appraisal report and the appraisal-clause settlement process are not the same job.

The original valuation is a defined product: inspect the evidence, research the market, select comparables, make the appropriate adjustments and issue an opinion of value.

Once a claim enters the appraisal clause, the amount of work becomes unpredictable. One file may resolve after a short exchange with the carrier's appraiser. Another may require repeated discussions, additional evidence, new comparable analysis, umpire selection, review of competing positions and preparation of final award documents.

The report tells you what the loss is worth. Settlement services are the additional work required to carry that valuation through the appraisal-clause process.

Appraiser-to-appraiser work

Communications and exchanges concerning the disputed amount of loss, supporting evidence and valuation methodology.

Additional analysis

Reviewing competing comparables, adjustments, documentation and new information that arises during the appraisal process.

Resolution documents

Preparing settlement memoranda, appraisal awards and other documents needed to conclude the amount-of-loss determination.

What settlement work can include

We stay with the file after the valuation is complete.

Diminished Value & Total Loss
  • Review the carrier's position and valuation support
  • Communicate with the opposing appraiser on the amount of loss
  • Exchange and analyze comparable vehicles and adjustments
  • Address challenges to the valuation evidence
  • Work toward an agreed amount of loss
  • Issue settlement memorandum or appraisal award documents
If the Appraisers Cannot Agree
  • Evaluate potential umpire candidates
  • Participate in the umpire-selection process
  • Organize the valuation evidence for umpire review
  • Present the disputed amount-of-loss positions
  • Review the resulting award documentation
  • Finalize the appraisal-clause file

The exact steps vary by policy language, jurisdiction and how quickly the two appraisers can reach agreement.

Settlement fee

$300 per hour for additional appraisal-clause work.

Settlement work is billed hourly because there is no reliable way to know in advance whether a file will require one hour or ten. You pay for the work actually performed rather than subsidizing more complex claims through a large flat settlement fee.

Standard settlement rate
$300 / hour

The fee is earned from the time spent performing additional appraisal-clause work.

Labor determines the fee. The amount of the recovery does not increase the hourly rate.

Normal client-protection cap
We normally limit the settlement-service bill to 25% of the additional recovery.

An open-ended hourly bill can make clients reluctant to pursue a legitimate claim. The cap is designed to keep the economics reasonable and prevent the settlement fee from consuming a disproportionate share of the client's improvement.

The cap does not increase the hourly bill. It only reduces the amount payable when 25% of the additional recovery is lower than the hourly charge.

amount payable = lesser of hourly fees earned or 25% client cap
How the cap works

The hourly charge comes first. The cap can only bring the bill down.

Assume four hours of settlement work at $300 per hour. The hourly fee earned is $1,200 in every example. The recovery only determines whether the client-protection cap reduces that amount.

Additional recovery Hourly fee earned 25% cap Client pays Result
$2,000 $1,200 $500 $500 $700 of earned time is written off.
$5,000 $1,200 $1,250 $1,200 The hourly bill governs.
$20,000 $1,200 $5,000 $1,200 A larger recovery does not increase the fee.
$100,000 $1,200 $25,000 $1,200 The fee is still based on four hours of labor.
Try the numbers

Settlement fee calculator

Claim Settlement Cost Calculator
payable = min(4 hrs × $300, 25% × $5,000)
Start with the result

How much additional recovery did we obtain?

$5,000
$0 $25k $50k $75k $100k
Hourly rate $300 / hour
Normal client cap 25%
Hours worked 4 hrs
Your settlement-service charge
$1,200
hourly fee governs
Hourly fees earned
$1,200
25% client ceiling
$1,250
What this means
Four hours of settlement work earns $1,200. Because the 25% cap is higher than the hourly charge, the client pays the hourly amount. A larger recovery would not increase this fee unless additional labor is performed.
Common questions

Claim settlement services explained

Do I always need settlement services after buying an appraisal?

No. If the insurer accepts the valuation or the claim resolves without further appraisal-clause work, there may be no settlement-service charge at all.

Why isn't settlement included in the appraisal price?

Because the workload is unknown. The valuation itself has a defined scope. Appraisal-clause work can take a short exchange or extend through multiple rounds and an umpire proceeding.

What exactly is billed at $300 per hour?

Additional time spent working the appraisal-clause dispute after the valuation is complete, including appraiser communications, valuation analysis, evidence review, umpire-related work and preparation of settlement or award documents.

Why cap the bill at 25%?

Because an uncapped hourly bill can become unreasonable relative to a small recovery. We normally use the 25% limit so clients can pursue legitimate disputes without worrying that settlement costs will consume the result.

Does a larger recovery automatically increase the settlement fee?

No. The fee is earned from billable time at $300 per hour. The 25% figure is a ceiling that can reduce the amount payable; it does not increase compensation above the hourly work performed.

Claim Settlement Solutions

When the valuation is done but the claim is not, we can stay with the appraisal process.

The objective is straightforward: carry the amount-of-loss dispute through the first-party appraisal-clause process efficiently, document the work and keep the client's settlement costs proportional to the result.

Settlement Hotline
Payment Page

Appraisal-clause procedures and requirements vary by insurance policy and jurisdiction. Appraisal generally concerns the amount of loss and does not itself determine coverage. Services are subject to the applicable policy terms, law and engagement agreement.

Need help moving an appraisal-clause claim toward resolution?

Contact Claim Settlement

get in touch

Any questions about our services?

We’re here to help. Fill out the form or call us now by clicking the button below. 

Our team of experts is happy to answer any questions you may have, big or small.