Hiring an appraiser can be a powerful way to resolve disputes when an insurance company refuses to pay the full cost of car repairs. However, whether it is a sound financial decision depends on the cause of the disagreement.
1. When an Appraiser is Often the Answer
The “Appraisal Clause” in your policy is designed to settle disagreements specifically regarding the cost or scope of damages. It is most effective when:
Technical Disputes Arise: Disagreements over complex repair methods, such as frame set-up, specialized paint blending, or manufacturer-mandated safety procedures (like ADAS calibrations).
Total Loss Valuation: If the insurer’s “Actual Cash Value” (ACV) offer for a totaled car is significantly lower than current market rates.
Specialty Vehicles: For custom, classic, or luxury cars where standard insurance databases may not accurately reflect true repair costs or value.
2. When an Appraiser May Not Help
Hiring an appraiser is often not a solution for policy-based or legal disputes:
The “Like Kind and Quality” (LKQ) Rule: Most policies allow insurers to use used, recycled, or aftermarket parts for older vehicles. If the dispute is simply that you want new factory (OEM) parts but the policy allows for LKQ, an appraiser cannot override the contract.
Coverage Denials: If the insurer claims the damage pre-existed the accident or isn’t covered by your policy, an appraiser cannot help. These are legal issues requiring an attorney or insurance regulator.
3. Evaluating the “Math” of an Appraisal
Before invoking the appraisal clause, consider the potential return on investment (ROI):
Fees: Independent appraisals typically cost between $250 and $750+ depending on the complexity.
Umpire Costs: If the two appraisers cannot agree, they must hire a neutral “umpire,” and you typically split that cost with the insurer.
Potential Gain: Statistics suggest the appraisal process can increase repair settlements significantly, with some data showing an average increase of over $5,300 for repair claims when undervalued. However, if the dispute is only over a few hundred dollars, the appraiser’s fee may exceed the extra money recovered.
Summary Table: Appraisal vs. Insurance Estimate
| Disagreement Over | Can an Appraiser Help? | Recommendation |
| Repair Method/Labor Hours | Yes | Hire an appraiser. |
| Vehicle Market Value | Yes | Hire an appraiser. |
| New OEM vs. Used Parts | Usually No | Review your policy first. |
| Whether damage is covered | No | Contact an attorney. |
The Bottom Line: If you think your estimate is too low, don’t rush to hire an expert. First, have a professional review the line items to determine if the conflict is about the cost of parts or the necessity of repair procedures.
Wondering if you need an appraiser? Fill the form below and we will review your case and advise.
